Just as prelude to this post, I would like to state that I feel the inevitable comparisons to Game of Thrones are unwarranted. The only things these two fantastic series have in common are that they are both a part of the fantasy genre. And that’s it. That’s where the similarities begin and end. However, the comparisons are inevitable and I’ve included it in this post for the sole purpose of proving a point.

This past week it was announced that, finally, a Wheel of Time TV series is being produced. This announcement was received, as usual, with a flood of both excitement and caution by fans of the series. Personally, I was over come with joy after hearing the news. I thought that it was wonderful that finally, this amazing (though slightly flawed series) is going to be brought to life on screen. I did however have some reservations. Reservations that I think most people would agree need to be handled with the proper care and attention for this series to be finely executed. 

Firstly, there is the issue of pacing. The show runners will have a mammoth task ahead of them. I think we can all agree that The Wheel of Time was insanely detailed and, at times, overly verbose. Everything was described in detail, and then repeated again a couple chapters down the line. In that respect, the show runners will have a simple task in that descriptive repetition is not needed in a visual medium. The difficult part for the show runners is going to be the streamlining of senseless plot lines that became convoluted over the series and “simplifying” the story for TV. This will no doubt anger hard core fans, but unfortunately, it is a necessary process that needs to be properly executed. Now this does not necessarily mean that plot lines need to be cut out or whole characters killed off (*glares at Game of Thrones*) but instead the show runners will need to streamline certain narratives by fast tracking the less interesting parts and spending more time on the parts that are more intriguing. For example, in The Great Hunt, there are many chapters showing Rand and the gang just traveling with no real exposition in between. The show can either choose to remove some of the traveling (and use establishing shots to inform the viewer of their current destination) or use the traveling time as expository moments. And while it pains me to see details cut out from TV and movie adaptations of books, I see the necessity in doing so and The wheel of time will need simplifying and streamlining much more than any other TV show or movie has had before. If the show runners are able to crack the code on the pacing and simplification issue, The Wheel of Time could become one of the greatest shows to ever air on television. 

Unfortunately, pacing is not the only issue that will be plaguing The Wheel of Time’s TV adaptation. The show runners are going to have to find a way to make this story appeal to a large audience. While Game of Thrones is a fantasy series, it is not your general, conventional fantasy like The Wheel of Time. It had its politics, sex and nudity, main character deaths and the fact that a lot of the show is grounded in reality (especially the first couple of seasons), to appeal to massive audiences. That is, arguably, why Game of Thrones has done so well (in addition to the great writing, directing, acting etc.) The Lord of the Rings is more of an apt comparison for The Wheel of Time in that it’s more of a classic fantasy and getting a mass audience behind classic fantasy is not as easy as it might seem. Personally, I have met many people who would look at you in derision when you discuss The Lord of The Rings but will join you in a heartbeat when you want to discuss anything about Game of Thrones. I believe that this is going to be The Wheel of Times greatest hurdle; especially in the first couple of books where the focus is mainly on channeling and the powers of each of the characters as opposed to the politics. 

Furthermore, the show will have to ensure that they cast the characters properly. Casting is probably the most crucial element in getting this show right. The producers are going to have to use some “Marvel Studio level” casting in that they have to cast correctly. Marvel Studios has yet to cast a character incorrectly. If the producers get the right actors, they will most definitely succeed. A list actors are not a necessity. Good actors are a necessity. The biggest hurdle here will be the marketing department. They will push for A list actors even if they do not fit the role; just so that they can put a name on a poster. The producers are going to have to stand their ground and insist on actors that are right for the role and not just because of their name. 

Lastly, this show is going to have to get a proper budget and will have to air on the correct network. Without a decent budget, this show will most definitely crumble. There is no way this show will be anywhere near decent if they’re stuck with a lousy budget. Last years’ dreadful Winters Dragon “prequel” is proof enough. However budget is not the only concern. The show will also have to have a proper home. There is no way this show will prosper on an ordinary network with censors and restriction. While The Wheel of Time doesn’t really have any nudity or sex in it per se, it is most definitely hinted at and if the show runners are anywhere near clever enough, they will exploit. However, the nudity and sex is not the reason this show needs a proper network. That reason is due to the violent nature of the series. The Wheel of Time is incredibly violent and while the details in the books aren’t near as gory as they could’ve been, it’s still an extremely violent series and I would hope that the show runners not hold back when it comes to this. HBO is obviously first choice, if possible. Netflix and Amazon are probably the next best thing if HBO decides they’re not interested. 

Honestly, I believe that The Wheel of time has the potential to be one of the greatest television series ever made. It has a rough road ahead of it but if the producers and show runners do their jobs properly and with great attention to detail, they may just be able to pull off something amazing. 

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Wheel of Time Adaptation 

  1. I think you nailed it pretty solidly. I, for one, thoroughly enjoyed Jordan’s word pictures, but there are just some things that don’t directly translate into video format. There is also definitely going to be some trouble what with Game of Thrones being so popular and the comparisons with Wheel of Time. Wheel of Time has a lot of characters in it, as well, but it isn’t nearly as political or “plot twisting” as Game of Thrones is (disclaimer: I haven’t read or watched a bit of GoT, so I could be completely wrong. . . oh, jeez, just realized we’ll now have WoT as well as GoT. . .).

    I thought the whole “make Wheel of Time into a TV show” thing was going to flop and not pan out, so to be honest, I’m kind of irked to hear it isn’t. Not because I’m a fan who thinks they’ll muck it up, though I do certainly fear that, but because I think they’re just jumping on the bandwagon due to how popular and successful GoT has become. Even if that’s not the case, I’m fairly certain that is how it will be perceived, and that will probably hurt it more than do it good. As a fantasy fan, I find it quite irritating that GoT is all the rave and anything else will be compared to it (which is why I haven’t read or watched it yet), but I can’t argue with the fact that every time I mention I haven’t watched Game of Thrones I’m met with a mixture of shock, disgust, and incredulity. That definitely says something about its success.

    Like

    1. Ah I never though of that, now we’re just going have people throwing around WoT all over the place 🙈. I know the comparisons are inevitable so I’m kinda just conditioning myself from now to just accept it lol. I really do hope that they’re not just jumping on the bandwagon and are actually doing the show because they believe that they can pull off a faithful adaptation and that they stick to the adaptation as season pass by unlike GoT where they veered off book around season 5. I know what you mean, the fact that you don’t watch GoT or have not read any of it is pretty blasphemous to some. To me it makes no difference. To each their own you know. However, I will suggest that if you do consider reading/watching GoT, that you do so after all the books have been published. The wait between books is excruciating and if you watch the show, it will spoil parts of it. That’s just fact at this point. I will say that I do think it deserves the recognition it gets (especially the books which are magnificent in mostly every way possible.)

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I’ll keep that in mind, thanks. I read the Name of the Wind and A Wise Man’s Fear. . . Haha, I know that wait. At least with WoT, all of the books are out and there is a conclusion already, so maybe the adaptation won’t suffer the same fate. There is something to be said for waiting until a series of written work has concluded before making it into another medium.

        Like

      2. That wait for Doors of Stone has been nearly as excruciating as the wait for Winds of Winter. At least Rothfuss doesn’t have a TV series barreling behind him and trying to takeover 😅. But I still love his books. His prose is some of the best I’ve ever read and the plot is just as intriguing.
        Thankfully with WoT I only started reading it once it was all out. Before then, I had never touched a single WoT book. I totally agree that sometimes it is just better to wait for an entire series to be completed 💯.

        Like

  2. Great analysis here! I’m currently on Book 9 of the WoT series. I share many of the same sentiments as you do. A-list actors simply will not do. Talented, young, emerging/new actors must be cast in the interest of creating a sustainable series. If the gameplan is to translate the entire series to screen, these actors are going to need to be talented and young. It’ll be a long journey if the series is received well.

    Known actors could fill the shoes of the Forsaken quite well. Perhaps a well-known grizzled actor could fill in Tam al’ Thor’s shoes. Smaller/less frequent roles can certainly feature some known talent.

    As for your point about sex/nudity being hinted at, you are right on. Jordan was very subtle about such content, but it was there, and TV execs can certainly exploit that. I don’t feel that doing such a thing is necessary, but by the same token, I hope the series is not catered to a teenage audience. I would hope the creators have full creative range to incorporate the content they need to illustrate the stakes, such as violence and certain concepts.

    Anywho, there is much to be said. Until more info comes out, I will remain skeptical. I love this series to death, and I only hope they can do it right. Great post!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s